Public-Private Partnership Policy Casebook/LaGuardia Central Terminal

admin 0
Public-Private Partnership Policy Casebook/LaGuardia Central Terminal

Abstract[edit]

In 1934, Fiorello LaGuardia, the famed mayor of New York Metropolis, boarded a TWA flight from Pittsburgh to New York Metropolis. Nevertheless, as soon as the airplane landed, the mayor was shocked to seek out himself in Newark, New Jersey and never New York Metropolis. He refused to go away the airplane and demanded to be flown to New York Metropolis or else. Lastly the pilots flew him to Floyd Bennett Area in Brooklyn the place Mayor LaGuardia disembarked from the airplane and held an press convention on the airfield. Mayor LaGuardia decried the state of affairs that the most important metropolis within the nation didn’t have an airport inside its personal boundaries, a lot much less its personal state. It was time that New York Metropolis will need to have its personal, trendy airport.[1] This was the delivery of what would grow to be LaGuardia Airport.

Three years later in 1937, New York Metropolis, in cooperation with the Works Progress Administration, started development of what was known as the New York Metropolis Municipal Airport in Flushing, Queens. Two years in a while October 15, 1939, the airport was devoted by Mayor LaGuardia and industrial flights began later in December 1939. The airport’s identify was shortly amended to grow to be New York Metropolis Municipal Airport-LaGuardia Area, earlier than turning into LaGuardia Airport in 1947.[2]

LaGuardia Airport has expanded over time and continues to function an important piece of the transportation infrastructure of the Better New York space. Nevertheless, the years haven’t been variety to the airport. Lack of upkeep, a complicated structure and the current flooding attributable to Hurricane Sandy in 2012 led Vice President Joe Biden to comment that LaGuardia seemed like an airport in “a 3rd world nation” in 2014.[3] It was clear that one thing needed to be achieved to LaGuardia Airport.

Throughout the years earlier than the Vice-President’s feedback, the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey had been getting ready to rebuild LaGuardia Airport as a public-private partnership. On Could 28, 2015, the Port Authority introduced they’d chosen LaGuardia Gateway Companions because the non-public entity to rebuild, finance, preserve and function the brand new Central Terminal Constructing at LaGuardia Airport.[4] This case research will examine the public-private partnership between the Port Authority and LaGuardia Gateway Companions. There’ll first be a listing of the actors concerned within the settlement, adopted by a timeline of the occasions which have led to the signing of the settlement. Following this introduction, the political and financial context of the settlement might be mentioned earlier than the narrative of the case is elaborated and the monetary construction of the deal is offered. Maps and different crucial diagrams might be offered as wanted all through these sections. Following the narrative of the case, the varied coverage points surrounding the settlement might be offered and mentioned earlier than concluding. Questions which are raised by the case research that have to be answered and mentioned are listed following the conclusion.

Annotated Record of Actors[edit]

Public Entities[edit]

State Of New York[edit]

One of many two states which are members of the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, a bi-state authority that presently maintains and operates LaGuardia Airport.[5]

  • Governor Andrew Cuomo– Governor of New York, elected in 2010 and the first proponent of the plan to rebuild the Central Terminal Constructing at LaGuardia Airport.[6]
  • New York State Division of Transportation– present homeowners of the Grand Central Parkway, which borders the southern fringe of LaGuardia Airport.
  • New York Metropolis– the present homeowners and unique builders of LaGuardia Airport, have leased the operations and upkeep of LaGuardia Airport to the Port Authority since 1947.[7] The present lease will expire in 2050.[8]
  • Airport Advisory Panel– a seven member panel appointed by Governor Cuomo in January 2015 to advise him and the Port Authority on how finest to modernize each LaGuardia Airport and John F. Kennedy Worldwide Airport. On July 27, 2015, their report, A 21st Century Airport for the State of New York: The New LaGuardia was launched to the general public.[9]

State of New Jersey[edit]

One of many two states which are members of the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, a bi-state authority that presently maintains and operates LaGuardia Airport.[10]

Port Authority of New York and New Jersey[edit]

A bi-state company created by the States of New York and New Jersey, together with america Congress, in 1921 and tasked with financing, constructing, working and sustaining port and different transportation infrastructure within the New York space.[11] Ruled by a Board of Commissioners. At present there are twelve members on the Board of Commissioners with every state’s Governor appointing six of them.[12] At present operates a number of bridges, port amenities, a mass transit system and LaGuardia Airport, in addition to 4 different airports within the New York area.[13]

Non-public Entities[edit]

LaGuardia Gateway Companions[edit]

The particular objective car created to be the non-public entity within the public-private partnership with the Port Authority.[14] They are going to be answerable for demolishing Terminal B and constructing the brand new Central Terminal Constructing and adjoining buildings.[15] LaGuardia Gateway Companions is made up of the next companions:

  • Vantage Airport Group– an fairness accomplice.[16] They’re the social gathering that’s partially accountable for growth and airport operations.[17] They’re additionally the group’s president.
  • Skanska Infrastructure Improvement– an fairness accomplice.[18] They’re the social gathering that’s partially accountable for the event and development of the mission.[19]
  • MI LaGuardia CTB, LLC (Meridiam)– an fairness accomplice.[20] They’re partially accountable for the event of the mission.[21]
  • Walsh Development– they’re partially accountable for the development of the mission. They don’t seem to be offering any fairness.[22]
  • Parsons Brinckerhoff– they’re partially accountable for the design of the mission. They don’t seem to be offering any fairness.[23]
  • Hellmuth, Obata & Kassabaum– they’re partially accountable for the design of the mission. They don’t seem to be offering any fairness.[24]
  • Morgan Stanley and Firm, LLC[25]
  • Citigroup International Markets, Inc.[26]
  • Wells Fargo Financial institution, N.A.[27]
  • Pragma Consulting[28]
  • O’Melveny & Meyers[29]
  • Campbell-Hill Aviation Group, LLC[30]

Delta Air Traces[edit]

The present leaser of terminals C and D at LaGuardia Airport. They’re accountable for the upkeep and operations of those parts of LaGuardia as a substitute of the Port Authority.[31] Delta’s terminals aren’t a part of this private-public partnership, however they’re anticipated to rebuild their terminals in an identical method to the brand new Central Terminal Constructing within the close to future.[32]

Timeline[edit]

  • 1934- Mayor LaGuardia refuses to get off his airplane at Newark Airport, calls for to be flown to New York and later requires the Metropolis of New York to have its personal airport.[33]
  • 1937- Development begins on the New York Municipal Airport in Flushing, Queens.[34]
  • 1939- New York Municipal Airport- LaGuardia Area opens for service.[35]
  • 1947- Port Authority of New York and New Jersey assume operations at LaGuardia Airport.[36]
  • 1964- Terminal B at LaGuardia Airport is accomplished and opened in time for the 1964 New York World’s Honest.[37]
  • 1983- Delta Air Traces opens Terminal D at LaGuardia Airport.[38]
  • 1992- Delta Air Traces opens Terminal C at LaGuardia Airport and builds a connection between it and Terminal D.[39]
  • 1995- Terminal A, also called the Marine Air Terminal, is designated as a historic landmark as a consequence of its standing as one of many oldest elements of LaGuardia Airport.[40]
  • October 26, 2012- The Port Authority points a request for {qualifications} for the Central Terminal Constructing Alternative Mission.[41]
  • July 26, 2013- The Port Authority pronounces 4 groups as prequalified to submit proposals for the Central Terminal Constructing Alternative Mission and invitations them to take action. The three groups are:
    • LaGuardia Gateway Companions- Vantage Airport Group Ltd., Skanska Infrastructure Improvement and MI LaGuardia CTB, LLC (Meridiam).[42]
    • LGAlliance- Macquarie Infrastructure and Actual Belongings, Inc. and Lend Lease Investments, Inc.[43]
    • LGA Central Terminal Consortium- ADP Administration & TAV Havalimanlari Holdings A.S., GS International Infrastructure Companions II L.P., GS Worldwide Infrastructure Companions II L.P.[44]
    • Aerostar New York Holdings- Highstar Capital IV L.P. and Aeropuerto de Cancun S.A. de C.V.[45]
  • February 6, 2014- Vice President Joe Biden states that LaGuardia Airport seems to be like an airport “in some third world nation”.[46]
  • March 10, 2014- Aerostar New York Holdings is disqualified by the Port Authority and faraway from the prequalified record of proposal submitters. The three remaining potential submitters are LaGuardia Gateway Companions, LGAlliance and LGA Central Terminal Consortium.[47]
  • October 2014- Governor Andrew Cuomo of New York pronounces {that a} competitors for brand spanking new grasp plans of LaGuardia and John F. Kennedy Airports can be held in an effort to decide how the airports can be modernized for the 21st century. An Airport Advisory Panel is created to assessment the submissions and use them make their last suggestions how one can finest develop the 2 airports.[48]
  • January 2015- Governor Cuomo appoints Dan Tishman because the chairman of the Airport Advisory Panel with the next members: Amanda Burden, Jose Gomez- Ibanez, Jackie Snyder, Tony Collins, Melinda Katz, John Zuccotti.[49]
  • February 25, 2015- The Port Authority delays its determination on their choice of non-public accomplice for the LaGuardia Central Terminal Constructing Alternative Mission. They state their determination will come after the Airport Advisory Panel has extra time to complete their last report. The bidders introduced they might wait till April for the Port Authority’s determination.[50]
  • April 2015- The Port Authority receives the preliminary suggestions from the Airport Advisory Panel.[51]
  • Could 28, 2015- The Port Authority pronounces that they’ve chosen LaGuardia Gateway Companions to be the non-public accomplice within the LaGuardia Central Terminal Constructing Alternative Mission. The Port Authority states that LaGuardia Gateway Companions proposal was the one which was most in step with the suggestions of the Airport Advisory Panel.[52]
  • July 27, 2015- Governor Andrew Cuomo and Vice President Joe Biden current to the general public the findings of the Airport Advisory Panel.[53] The complete report, A 21st Century Airport for the State of New York: The New LaGuardia: A Report back to the Governor from the Airport Advisory Panel: Guiding Ideas for a Complete Airport Grasp Plan can be launched to the general public.[54]
  • 2016- Anticipated date of monetary shut between the Port Authority and LaGuardia Gateway Companions.[55]
  • Early 2016- Deliberate date for demolition of the present Terminal B and development of the brand new Central Terminal Constructing to start.[56]
  • Mid 2019- Main work on Central Terminal Constructing anticipated to be accomplished.[57]
  • 2021- Central Terminal Constructing Alternative Mission is anticipated to be absolutely constructed and open for operations.[58]

Narrative of The Case[edit]

In 2004, the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey (PANYNJ) launched into a significant modernization/redevelopment program to treatment the purposeful inefficiencies of the LaGuardia Airport Central Terminal Constructing, also called Terminal B (the “CTB”). The LGA Redevelopment Program consists of two separate, however associated parts – the CTB alternative mission, which incorporates the design, finance, development, upkeep and operations of a brand new CTB and associated amenities, to be carried out by a personal consortium (or its designee) beneath a public-private partnership with the Port Authority (the “CTB Alternative Mission”); and a capital infrastructure program, which incorporates the design, development, and operation and upkeep of sure supporting amenities on the Airport, to be carried out by the Port Authority or its contractors.[59]

The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey (PANYNJ) launched its request for {qualifications} for the LaGuardia Central Terminal Constructing Alternative Mission in October 2012.[60] Sixteen groups made up of contractors, fairness members and different key companies responded to the authority’s RFQs. The Port Authority issued the preliminary Request for Proposals (the “RFP”) for the CTB Alternative Mission on August 28, 2013, and, after contemplating feedback from varied potential members with respect to this preliminary RFP, the ultimate RFP was launched on April 24, 2014. PANYNJ then picked the next 4 groups to submit their request for proposals (RFP)[61]:

  • Aerostar New York Holdings LLC, which incorporates Highstar Capital IV LP, Aeropuerto de Cancun S.A. de C.V.
  • LaGuardia Gateway Companions, which incorporates Skanska Infrastructure Improvement, Tishman Development Corp. of New York, Parsons Brinckerhoff, Meridiam, Hellmuth, Obata + Kassabaum PC, and Vantage Airport Group Ltd.
  • LGAlliance, New York, which incorporates Lend Lease (US) Development LMB Inc., Macquarie Capital Group Ltd., and Hochtief AirPort GmbH
  • LGA Central Terminal Consortium, which incorporates STV Inc., ADP Administration & TAV Havalimanlari Holding A.S, GS International Infrastructure Companions II, L.P. and GS Worldwide Infrastructure Companions II, L.P.

Proposals from solely three of the above groups had been acquired on Could 20, 2014. The Aerostar was disqualified in March 2014.[62] The Port Authority reviewed and evaluated the proposals over an roughly five-month interval. Based mostly on such assessment, in October 2014 workers formulated a suggestion with respect to the choice of a most well-liked proposer, based mostly on a best-value dedication.[63]

The Port Authority was anticipated to pick out a profitable group within the fall of 2014 however the determination was delayed after New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo in October launched a contest to revamp La Guardia and different New York airports.[64]

In January 2015, Governor Cuomo created a seven-member panel to recommendation the Governor and the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey (PANYNJ) on the modernization of LaGuardia.[65]

Andrew Cuomo’s Panel consisted of seven people[66]:

  • Chair – Dan Tishman (Vice chairman at AECOM Know-how Company and Chairman and CEO of Tishman Actuality and Development)
  • Amanda Burden (former NYC Planning Commissioner and present principal at Bloomberg Associates),
  • Tony Collins (Co-Chair for the North Nation Regional Financial Improvement Council)
  • Jose Gomez-Ibanez (Professor of City Planning and Public Coverage at Harvard’s Kennedy College of Authorities and Harvard’s Graduate College of Design)
  • Melinda Katz (Queens Borough President)
  • Jackie Snyder (Particular advisor for infrastructure for New York State and the previous head of the NYC Design Fee)
  • John Zuccotti (Co-chairman of Brookfield Workplace Properties and chairman of the board of administrators of Brookfield Monetary Properties LLC)

In April 2015, the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey (PANYNJ) Board acquired a sequence of preliminary suggestions from the Advisory Panel associated to LaGuardia Airport, and the actions being taken in the present day incorporate a variety of parts of these preliminary suggestions, and characterize the primary part of a holistic Grasp Plan for LaGuardia Airport.[67] Cuomo’s panel’s suggestions had been impressed by Governor Cuomo’s cost not simply to transform or rebuild the present amenities. The Advisory Panel targeted on a complete imaginative and prescient for the airport that has been missing over the a long time of its prior growth. The Advisory Panel additionally put a deal with placing passengers first and bettering their expertise, beginning with ow they get to the airport.[68]

In Could 2015, the Port Authority’s Board of Commissioners voted to pick out LaGuardia Gateway Companions to develop a $3.6 billion world-class facility to serve roughly 50% of the passenger quantity at LaGuardia. It must be famous that this vote was in step with the suggestions of New York Governor Cuomo’s Airport Advisory Panel. The LaGuardia Gateway Companions[69]

On the June 25, 2015 Port Authority of New York & New Jersey board assembly, the Board licensed sure contract awards and expenditures for Program Supply Providers in reference to the New LGA Redevelopment Program (Program) and to help the combination of the New Terminal B Mission with different ongoing development tasks on the airport.[70]

Development on the primary half will start upon last approval from the Board of Administrators of the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey. That approval is anticipated within the first a part of 2016; nearly all of this primary half of the mission is anticipated to open to passengers in 2019, with full completion scheduled for roughly 18 months later.[71]

Mission Overview[edit]

The brand new LaGuardia Airport airport would consolidate 4 terminals into one, join the power to the New York Metropolis subway system, create extra space for airplane taxiways and add a resort. The brand new terminal will enable for expanded taxiway space to make sure that airplane actions on the bottom are extra environment friendly. The important thing parts of the work are the whole rebuilding of the terminal and airport buildings and the institution of a high-speed ferry and an AirTrain station that might be related to the NYC subway system at Willets Level.[72] The LaGuardia Airport redevelopment program consists of two phases.

Why is it Being Finished?[edit]

The Central Terminal Constructing at LaGuardia Airport is each outdated and overcrowded. Opened in 1964 for that years World’s Honest, the CTB was final renovated within the 1990s and in the present day handles most of the 24 million passengers that use the airport.[73] It’s estimated that even with out taking any motion in the present day, by 2030 nearly 17.5 million passengers will use the CTB, nearly double the quantity of passengers that the constructing was designed for.[74] The present design of the CTB was constructed for an easier time in aviation and subsequently doesn’t have sufficient flooring area to fulfill all Transportation Safety Administration requirements for personnel lodging, screening processes and baggage checking gear used in the present day.[75] Along with the CTB itself, the parking garages that help the airport are additionally nearing the tip of their lives and have to be changed in addition to a number of items of the utility infrastructure, a few of which date again to the 1930s when the airport was first constructed.[76] Lastly, the airport ramp, the world the place planes board and disembark passengers on the concourses, was designed within the 1960s when planes had been smaller than they’re in the present day. Which means that in the present day’s bigger, quieter and extra environment friendly plane are unable to entry the CTB as a consequence of dimension constraints.[77] The design additionally hinders the smaller planes that presently use the airport as they’re unable to energy into and out of positions on the concourses beneath their very own energy, necessitating the use towing gear, which wastes time, cash and sources.[78]

LaGuardia Airport Mission Breakdown

What’s Being Constructed?[edit]

Section 1 – Assemble a brand new Terminal B (Central Terminal) with Central Arrival and Departure Corridor. Present airways who function out of Terminal B (CTB) embrace the next[79]:

  • Air Canada
  • American
  • Frontier
  • Jet Blue
  • Southwest
  • United
  • Virgin American

Section 2- Redevelop Terminals C & D and Connect with Central Arrival and Departure Corridor. This part might be accomplished by Delta. No agenda is ready for the competitors date for this part.[80] Delta’s present lease at Terminals C & D expires within the subsequent two years. It must be famous that the airline and the port authority must negotiate a deal.[81]

The New LaGuardia Airport Redevelopment Program consists two main subprojects the LGA Capital Infrastructure Renewal program (LGACI Program), the price of which is presently forecast at $1.1 billion, and the New Terminal B Mission, to be applied by means of the public-private partnership (P3).[82]

The LGACI Program is a set of tasks that handle short- and long-term infrastructure wants at LGA, reminiscent of utility and electrical infrastructure, parking, roadways, bridges, and choose constructing demolitions. Initiatives beneath the LGACI Program are required to take care of a will make investments about $190m on the East Parking Storage and East Finish Substation mission. The East Parking Storage will contain an funding of $82.9m. The runway modernization will price $202.9m.[83]

The New Terminal B Mission supplies for the design, finance, development, upkeep and operation of a brand new Terminal B and associated amenities, to be carried out by LaGuardia Gateway Companions beneath the public-private partnership (P3). The plans for the New Terminal B name for a brand new 35-gate facility with extra eating places, shops, greater gate areas and improved passenger and baggage screening. The redesigned facility will use a system wherein passengers get to their gates by means of raised pedestrian bridges, serving to to create extra space for planes to taxi and guaranteeing fewer delays. The brand new CTB can even function 214 check-in counters and kiosks, baggage dealing with techniques with a centralised in-line, a baggage screening facility, and 1,620ft of luggage declare system presentation frontage.[84]

LaGuardia Gateway Companions – DBFOM (P3)

  • Structural Demolition – Abatement, deconstruction and elimination of the next buildings is important to make means for the brand new CTB: Present CTB, Hanger 1, present CTB P2 parking storage, departures degree roadway bridge buildings, and the decommissioned Central Electrical Substation.
  • Development of momentary amenities to help passenger companies throughout development of the alternative CTB (new CTB).
  • CTB Alternative – Roughly 1.Three million sq. foot with 35 constructing contact gates, expandable to 38 gates and related plane apron and Frontage Roads.
  • CTB Central Entry Portal – Create a unifying architectural expertise that hyperlinks terminal B and C for the primary time, accommodates facilities and retail for coming into and transiting passengers, and accommodates the longer term growth of the next parts: individuals mover, air practice station, and a resort and convention facility.
  • CTB Apron Modifications – 35 new plane apron gates, supported by a taxi lane system with a number of startup positions and in a single day parking lodging for plane, adjoining to the brand new terminal and built-in with the present taxiway configuration.
  • Frontage Roads – Features a multilevel bridge for departures and arrivals visitors, adjoining to the brand new CTB, with a excessive occupancy car (HOV) lane at grade roadway beneath.
  • Utilities on CTB web site– telecommunications, water, pure fuel, sewer, storm and electrical service connections to the brand new CTB.
  • Central Heating & Refrigeration Plant (CHRP) – A brand new three story stand-alone construction that can home chillers, scorching water mills and different gear to switch and improve the present plant that serves the present CTB.
  • Hydrant Fueling – Contains the set up of underground fueling infrastructure throughout the new CTB ramp space in an effort to help the implementation of a future hydrant fueling system at LGA.
  • Operation, upkeep and administration of the present CTB and momentary amenities throughout development, the brand new CTB and CHRP.[85]

LGA Capital Infrastructure Renewal Program (LGACI Program) – Funded and managed by the Port Authority of NY & NJ (public)

  • Demo Hangars 2 & 4
  • Assemble new East Finish Substation
  • Assemble new East Parking Storage
  • Assemble Utility Trunk Line at East and West

Who Has What Obligations and Dangers?[edit]

Port Authority Obligations[86]:

  • Airport Operator
  • PFC funding
  • Airport infrastructure funding
  • Receive environmental approvals
  • Approve design/development submissions
  • Relocate airport-wide capabilities out of present CTB

LaGuardia Gateway Companions[87]:

  • Full development at mounted worth on schedule
  • Present further funding together with fairness
  • Function and preserve Mission for 35-years
  • Pay annual hire plus income share
  • Handle all airline pushed modifications
  • Negotiate all New Terminal B subleases
  • Carry out life cycle enhancements and return the Terminal on the finish of the Lease time period in required situation

The place is the Financing/Funding Coming From?[edit]

The fairness for LaGuardia Gateway Companions a part of the LGA Redevelopment Program will come from three firms[88]:

The debt financing for the LaGuardia Gateway Companions a part of the LGA Redevelopment Program will come from two firms[89]:

  • Citigroup International Markets
  • Wells Fargo

The precise particulars of the quantities invested by all above listed accomplice firms won’t be official till the monetary shut is full. The anticipated date of monetary shut between the Port Authority and LaGuardia Gateway Companions is scheduled to happen within the early months of 2016.[90]

How Lengthy is the Deal Going to Final?[edit]

The deal will final 35 years or till 2050. LaGuardia Gateway Companions will function and preserve the brand new CTB (Terminal B) Mission for 35-years after which flip over the brand new CTB to the Port Authority of NY & NJ.[91]

Coverage Points[edit]

Design Points: How a lot energy ought to one other public entity have over the design of a Non-public-Public Partnership?[edit]

When the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey (PANYNJ) launched its request for {qualifications} for the LaGuardia Central Terminal Constructing Alternative Mission in October 2012, they anticipated to complete the choice course of by the tip of the fourth quarter of 2013.[92] As a substitute, the choice was made through the second quarter of 2015. Whereas delays aren’t unknown throughout request for proposals, one placing function of this delay was that the mission that was outlined within the RFQ and Briefing E-book in 2012 solely bears slight resemblance to the mission that was introduced in 2015, after PANYNJ took into consideration the solutions made by Governor Cuomo’s Airport Advisory Panel.

The preliminary plans for the mission was for the brand new Central Terminal Constructing to be the one portion of LaGuardia to be rebuilt. Terminals C and D had been going to be related to the brand new constructing, however not rebuilt.[93] Along with this extra restricted goal, the design for the plane concourse piers, the place the planes would dock and passengers embark and disembark, was comparatively typical. Two piers with a 48 foot broad central concourse and 25 foot broad holding rooms on both aspect would jut out from the Central Terminal Constructing the place planes would dock.[94] The mission total would resemble the piers used within the newer sections of Reagan Washington Nationwide Airport.

The design offered by the Airport Advisory Panel, whereas comparable in construction, included two main departures from the RFQ. First, your complete airport, together with Terminals C and D can be rebuilt as a single unified construction, although the Central Terminal Constructing would stay a separate mission and be the only focus of the private-public partnership.[95] Second, the design of the piers can be modified dramatically. As a substitute of the standard type piers envisioned within the RFQ, the brand new piers would use an island-gate system. On this system every of the 4 piers (two on the Central Terminal Constructing and one every at Terminals C and D) can be an island, fully separate from the principle terminal constructing. They might be related to the terminal constructing by bridges that may be excessive sufficient to permit plane to cross beneath them and entry all sides of the island.[96]

Whereas it’s tough to find out how a lot the Airport Advisory Panel delayed PANYNJ’s determination, it’s recognized that after they determined to delay their determination in February 2015, the rationale they gave was as a result of Airport Advisory Panel.[97] As soon as they acquired the Panel’s findings, they made their determination and said that the ultimate design can be in step with the suggestions of the panel.[98]

Financial Points[edit]

Delta Airways, which operates terminal A of the LaGuardia airport, will renovate its terminal. Most not too long ago, Delta Airways introduced a September quarter revenue, with an adjusted pre-tax earnings of $2.2B, with an adjusted earnings of $1.74 per diluted share, “Delta returned $532 by means of dividends”[99]. This alternative has proved to be a sound alternative for Delta Airways.

The LaGuardia Gateway Partnership will present capital fairness financing. Fairness is the most costly type of financing; usually, debt is cheaper than fairness. Moreover, debt is repaid first, earlier than fairness is repaid. The advantages of the P3 mannequin are that the non-public sector absorbs price overruns. One financial problem to this P3 is income threat. The LaGuardia reconstruction mission doesn’t search to increase runway capability. Restricted runway capability could scale back the variety of planes that the airport can handle, thereby limiting income. Nevertheless, income could also be generated from flight ticket taxes, concessions, and airline firms. The LaGuardia Gateway Partnership should account for the demand and income threat is its financing construction, in order no to fall prey to optimism bias.

Most significantly, LaGuardia faces demand threat from its low recognition, and poor repute. As an illustration LaGuardia was voted the Worst Airport in North America 2015, a current ballot cited “ The terminals appear to develop extra decrepit annually (…) lengthy queues manned by unfriendly workers”[100] The rework just isn’t a assure for improved demand. Moreover, the proposed AirTrain mission must be accomplished earlier than the renovation mission is full in an effort to enhance comfort of journey from Queens to Manhattan.

The delays and redesigns attributable to the Airport Advisory Panel does elevate the query of if the Port Authority is in full management of their very own public-private partnership. Whereas each the Port Authority and LaGuardia Gateway Companions could have the identical targets and goals for the mission, they may not fully line up with these of the Airport Advisory Panel, which provides uncertainty to the mission and subsequently elevated prices.

Airport Privatization: Is LaGuardia an instance of this?[edit]

In 2014, one of many teams within the public-private partnership coverage class did a case research on the current privatization of Luis Munoz Worldwide Airport in San Juan, Puerto Rico. Privatized in 2013, it was hailed as the primary profitable privatization of a big scale industrial airport within the nation beneath the Federal Aviation Administration’s Pilot Program for Airport Privatization.[101] Whereas each the public-private partnership that privatized Luis Munoz Worldwide Airport (a finance, function, preserve and enhance partnership)[102] and the public-private partnership that can construct the brand new Central Terminal Constructing at LaGuardia Airport (finance, design, construct, function and preserve partnership)[103] look like very comparable, the LaGuardia CTB mission just isn’t being developed beneath the FAA’s Pilot Program for Airport Privatization.[104] This doesn’t imply that at a future time it may very well be. The present operator of LaGuardia Airport, the Port Authority, has expertise with airport privatization, having privatized its operation at Stewart Worldwide Airport in Newburgh, New York in 2000.[105] They resumed operation of Stewart Worldwide Airport seven years later.

Sustainability and Local weather Change: What to do after Sandy?[edit]

In 2012, Hurricane Sandy brought on large injury to the states of New York and New Jersey on the whole and LaGuardia Airport specifically. The airport’s runways had been flooded with over 100 million gallons of seawater.[106] The airport was closed for 2 days, impacting 250,000 passengers and creating an financial lack of $108 million for the area.[107] It additionally served as a warning that for LaGuardia, situated on Flushing Bay, this might and possibly would occur once more sooner or later.

The RFQ issued by the Port Authority was despatched out on October 26, 2012, simply days earlier than Hurricane Sandy made landfall. But it included provisions that may assist the airport survive one other storm like Sandy, together with having the East Finish Substation and the Central Heating and Refrigeration Plant, which would supply energy, heating and air con to your complete airport, on the landward aspect of the airport, situated between Terminal C and the Grand Central Parkway.[108] The Airport Advisory Panel additional beneficial that different vital infrastructure is elevated and guarded in case of one other storm like Sandy.[109] Nevertheless, it must be famous that the Airport Advisory Panel’s suggestion of relocating and rebuilding Terminals C and D would place them the place the East Finish Substation and Central Heating and Refrigeration Plant are alleged to go.[110]

[edit]

New York Metropolis is the most important metropolis in america. This implies every time one thing is constructed or rebuilt, communities all through the town, particularly these close to the positioning, are going to be impacted. The LaGuardia Airport Central Terminal Constructing Alternative Mission isn’t any exception. It’s estimated that greater than 600,000 individuals and 50 colleges are situated inside 5 miles of LaGuardia. The East Elmhurst neighborhood is situated throughout the Grand Central Parkway from the airport.

The influence of the mission on the local people was a significant curiosity of each the Port Authority and the Airport Advisory Panel. Parking on the native streets by these ready to choose up individuals from LaGuardia has all the time been an issue in East Elmhurst. The Port Authority acknowledged this and within the RFQ included the development of a brand new 2,800 spot parking storage as a part of the mission.[111] The Panel approves of this motion, however means that it’s elevated to three,100 spots.[112] In addition they steered the creation of a chosen cellular phone ready space for pickups.[113]

Along with the parking issues created by LaGuardia Airport, noise attributable to planes taking off and touchdown on the airport continues to be an issue for native residents. For years there was a fringe rule in impact at LaGuardia Airport, limiting flights to locations which are lower than 1,500 miles away.[114] This was achieved partially to cut back noise, as was the principles that forestall plane from taking off or touchdown from LaGuardia through the hours between midnight and 6 within the morning.[115] The RFQ made no touch upon these restrictions, apart from making the certified proposers conscious of their existence earlier than they submitted their plans. The Airport Advisory Panel, whereas sympathetic to the native residents considerations, said that they felt that the brand new LaGuardia Airport must be constructed massive sufficient to accommodate bigger plane if the perimeter rule was eliminated someday sooner or later.[116]

Neighborhood Stakeholders and M/WBE companies [edit]

The LaGuardia Central Terminal Constructing Alternative mission has help from Governor Cuomo. Nevertheless, the LaGuardia Gateway Partnership must earn the belief and political help from native political leaders together with, State Senator James Sanders (D), and U.S. Rep. Gregory Meeks (D-Jamaica). There are political dangers from the shortage of inclusion minority and girls owned enterprises (M/WBE) within the fairness of the mission. It is very important have native political help too, because the Metropolis of New York owns the asset, the LaGuardia airport. “It is very important embrace and acknowledge group curiosity too”, State Sen. Jose Peralta (D-East Elmhurst).[117]. The area people stands to realize economically from elevated employment oppourtunities. Queens has a excessive unemployment fee for minorities, 6.8% in comparison with Whites at 3.4%. [118]

There’s a small alternative for minority enterprise inclusion within the fairness financing to the LaGuardia Central Terminal Alternative mission. On October 6, 2015, MPAC (Mobilizing Preachers and Communities) met with representatives from Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s workplace to debate the shortage of fairness from minority and girls owned enterprise within the mission. Particularly, MPAC desires “prime degree” inclusion of MWBE,[119]. To that finish, MPAC is supporting Transportation Consortium of New York as a possible fairness accomplice, able to contributing $60M in fairness.[120] Moreover, the Transportation Consortium of New York consists of Switzer Group and Manning Architects, which assist to design the Dallas and Atlanta airports.Moreover, Skanska was investigated for practices that drawback MWBE (Minority and Girls-owned Enterprise Enterprise) in 2011, and paid $19.6M to the U.S. authorities. Skanska was not discovered responsible, however settled with the united statesgovernment in line with Elizabeth Miller, Skanska Communication Director for the N.E. area.[121]

Governor Cuomo has expressed help for MWBE’s; he desires to make sure that 30% of the contract and subcontracts go to New York based mostly minority and girls owned enterprises.[122]. MPAC leaders are not looking for minority owned enterprise to be relegated to the subcontractor degree.[123] Nevertheless, no contractors might be determined upon till the official monetary closing which has but to be concluded. Minority inclusion is necessary to the Port Authority, as said in its ADCBE (Airport Concession Deprived Enterprise Enterprises) targets.[124]

PPP tasks want a number of political champions; Governor Andrew Cuomo supplies help from the State degree, U.S. Consultant Joseph Crowley (14th-Congressional District) supplies help on the nationwide degree, and State Senators James Sanders (D-10th Senate District) and Jose Peralta (D-13th Senate District) present each local people and State help. The Port Authority is the lessor of the Guardia Airport. The LaGuardia Central Terminal Alternative mission has help from Patrick Foye, the Port Authority Govt Director.

The LaGuardia Central Terminal Alternative mission will price $3.6B, with $1B supplied through public funds and $2.5B supplied through LaGuardia Gateway Companions. Nevertheless, solely 18,000 jobs (8,000 direct jobs, and 10,000 oblique jobs) might be created. Furthermore, the LaGuardia airport presently provides $16B in financial exercise, and supplies 121,000 jobs immediately.

Potential Additions: When is it Actually Finished and Does It Want a Resort?[edit]

When the development ends on the LaGuardia Airport Central Terminal Constructing Alternative Mission, it won’t be the tip of all growth on the web site. Regardless that not a single shovel of grime has been turned, already future plans for LaGuardia are being made. The most important is the development of a rail connection between the airport and the New York Metropolis Subway. LaGuardia Airport is presently the one main airport within the New York area that isn’t related to the subway or commuter rail system.[125] Already John F. Kennedy Worldwide Airport and Newark Liberty Worldwide Airport have AirTrains connecting the terminals on to commuter rail and subway stations.[126] Each the Port Authority and the Airport Advisory Panel help this plan. The RFQ included data on the present proper of means that has been reserved for the development of a rail connection to the airport and the way it could join immediately with the finished Central Terminal Constructing.[127] The mission additionally has the help of Governor Andrew Cuomo.[128] Along with a rail connection between the airport and the town at massive, the Airport Advisory Panel beneficial that the airport be designed to incorporate a enterprise and convention middle as nicely area for the potential development of a “200 room boutique resort” on the airport itself.[129] Neither the resort or convention middle are mentioned within the RFQ.

Dialogue Questions[edit]

1. What’s the acceptable degree of involvement for Governor Cuomo’s Airport Advisory Panel? How would possibly the panel’s imaginative and prescient (which differs from the preliminary RFP) impact the result of the LGA Central Terminal Constructing Alternative Mission?

2. Will this PPP overcome overcome the restrictions of the amenities ( lack of expanded runway area, lack of exhausting AirTrain connection to subway) at LGA?

3. Is the income threat transferred to the suitable social gathering, ( LaGuardia Gateway Companions, Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, the airways, the purchasers)?

4. How does this PPP illustrate the significance of a political champion?

Sources[edit]

  1. LaGuardia Turns 75: An In-Depth Have a look at the Airport’s Distinguished Historical past, NYC Aviation, final modified October 15, 2014, http://www.nycaviation.com/2014/10/la-guardia-airport-celebrates-75-years/#.VienWH6rTIU
  2. Ibid.
  3. Adam Edelman, “Vice President Biden Blasts LaGuardia Airport as feeling like “it is in some third world nation”,” New York Every day Information, February 6, 2014, http://www.nydailynews.com/information/politics/vice-president-biden-blasts-la-guardia-airport-feeling-world-country-article-1.1604900
  4. Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, Port Authority Board Votes to Transfer Ahead on LaGuardia Airport Redevelopment, Could 28, 2015 (New York Metropolis: PANYNJ, 2015),http://www.panynj.gov/press-room/press-item.cfm?headLine_id=2218
  5. Historical past of the Port Authority, Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, accessed October 20, 2015, http://www.panynj.gov/about/history-port-authority.html.
  6. Governor Cuomo Unveils Imaginative and prescient For Transformative Redesign of LaGuardia Airport, Workplace of the Governor of New York, July 27, 2015, https://www.governor.ny.gov/information/governor-cuomo-unveils-vision-transformative-redesign-laguardia-airport.
  7. Airport Advisory Panel, A 21st Century Airport for the State of New York: The New LaGuardia (Albany: Workplace of the Governor of New York, 2015), 6.
  8. Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, LaGuardia Central Terminal Constructing Alternative Mission: Mission Briefing E-book for RFQ #31224, (New York Metropolis: PANYNJ, October 26, 2012), 44.
  9. Airport Advisory Panel, A 21st Century Airport for the State of New York: The New LaGuardia,1-13.
  10. Historical past of the Port Authority, Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, accessed October 20, 2015, http://www.panynj.gov/about/history-port-authority.html
  11. Ibid.
  12. PANYNJ, LaGuardia Airport Central Terminal Constructing Alternative Mission Briefing E-book, 2.
  13. Overview of Services and Providers, Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, accessed October 20, 2015, http://www.panynj.gov/about/facilities-services.html.
  14. PANYNJ, Port Authority Board Votes to Transfer Ahead on LaGuardia Airport Redevelopment, Could 28, 2015,http://www.panynj.gov/press-room/press-item.cfm?headLine_id=2218
  15. Ibid.
  16. Prequalified Lists, Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, Accessed on September 23, 2015,http://panynj.data/business-opportunities/ca-pre-qualified-lists.html
  17. PANYNJ, Port Authority Board Votes to Transfer Ahead on LaGuardia Airport Redevelopment, Could 28, 2015,http://www.panynj.gov/press-room/press-item.cfm?headLine_id=2218
  18. Prequalified Lists, PANYNJ, Accessed on September 23, 2015,http://panynj.data/business-opportunities/ca-pre-qualified-lists.html
  19. PANYNJ, Port Authority Board Votes to Transfer Ahead on LaGuardia Airport Redevelopment, Could 28, 2015,http://www.panynj.gov/press-room/press-item.cfm?headLine_id=2218
  20. Prequalified Lists, PANYNJ, Accessed on September 23, 2015,http://panynj.data/business-opportunities/ca-pre-qualified-lists.html
  21. PANYNJ, Port Authority Board Votes to Transfer Ahead on LaGuardia Airport Redevelopment, Could 28, 2015,http://www.panynj.gov/press-room/press-item.cfm?headLine_id=2218
  22. Ibid.
  23. Ibid.
  24. Ibid.
  25. Prequalified Lists, PANYNJ, Accessed on September 23, 2015,http://panynj.data/business-opportunities/ca-pre-qualified-lists.html
  26. Ibid.
  27. Ibid.
  28. Ibid.
  29. Ibid.
  30. Ibid.
  31. Airport Advisory Panel, A 21st Century Airport for the State of New York: The New LaGuardia,6.
  32. Ibid., 7
  33. LaGuardia Turns 75: An In-Depth Have a look at the Airport’s Distinguished Historical past, NYC Aviation, final modified October 15, 2014, http://www.nycaviation.com/2014/10/la-guardia-airport-celebrates-75-years/#.VienWH6rTIU
  34. Ibid.
  35. Ibid.
  36. Robert Caro, The Energy Dealer: Robert Moses and the Fall of New York, (New York Metropolis:Knopf, 1974), 767.
  37. Airport Advisory Panel, A 21st Century Airport for the State of New York: The New LaGuardia, 6.
  38. Ibid.
  39. Ibid.
  40. Ibid.
  41. PANYNJ, LaGuardia Airport Central Terminal Constructing Alternative Mission Briefing E-book, 1.
  42. Miguel Martin, “Megaprojects 460: One other Delay for LaGuardia Airport P3,” InfraPPP, February 25, 2015, http://infrapppworld.com/2015/02/megaproject-406-another-delay-for-laguardia-airport-p3.html.
  43. Ibid.
  44. Ibid.
  45. Ibid.
  46. Adam Edelman, “Vice President Biden Blasts LaGuardia Airport as feeling like “it is in some third world nation”, New York Every day Information, February 6, 2014.
  47. LaGuardia Airport Redevelopment Program, Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, Accessed on September 23, 2015,http://panynj.gov/airports/lgareimagined/
  48. Airport Advisory Panel, A 21st Century Airport for the State of New York: The New LaGuardia, 6.
  49. Ibid, Again Cowl.
  50. Miguel Martin, “Megaprojects 460: One other Delay for LaGuardia Airport P3,” InfraPPP, February 25, 2015.
  51. PANYNJ, Port Authority Board Votes to Transfer Ahead on LaGuardia Airport Redevelopment, Could 28, 2015,http://www.panynj.gov/press-room/press-item.cfm?headLine_id=2218
  52. Ibid.
  53. Governor Cuomo Unveils Imaginative and prescient For Transformative Redesign of LaGuardia Airport, Workplace of the Governor of New York, July 27, 2015, https://www.governor.ny.gov/information/governor-cuomo-unveils-vision-transformative-redesign-laguardia-airport.
  54. Airport Advisory Panel, A 21st Century Airport for the State of New York: The New LaGuardia, 1-13.
  55. Reuters, “UPDATE 2-Skanska consortium most well-liked bidder for $3.6 bln LaGuardia mission”, Could 29, 2015, http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/05/29/skanska-laguardia-idUSL5N0YK0VR20150529.
  56. Irwin Rapoport, “Cleared for Takeoff: LaGuardia’s $4B Enterprise,” ConstructionEquipmentGuide.com, August 12, 2015, http://constructionequipmentguide.com/Cleared-for-Takeoff-LaGuardia’s-4B-Enterprise/25929/.
  57. Ibid.
  58. Miguel Martin, “Megaprojects 460: One other Delay for LaGuardia Airport P3,” InfraPPP, February 25, 2015.
  59. Port Authority of New York and New Jersey (PANYNJ) (2015, Could 28). Could 28, 201. Retrieved from http://www.panynj.gov/path/pdf/PA-Minutes-5-28-15.pdf.
  60. Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, LaGuardia Central Terminal Constructing Alternative Mission: Mission Briefing E-book for RFQ #31224, (New York Metropolis: PANYNJ, October 26, 2012)
  61. http://www.governor.ny.gov/information/governor-cuomo-unveils-vision-transformative-redesign-laguardia-airport Worrell, C. (2013, August 2). Retrieved from ENR New York: http://www.enr.com/articles/11481-update-4-teams-shortlisted-for-2-4b-laguardia-terminal-building-replacement
  62. Martin, M. (2015, February 25). InfraPPP. Retrieved from http://infrapppworld.com/2015/02/megaproject-406-another-delay-for-laguardia-airport-p3.html
  63. Port Authority of New York and New Jersey (PANYNJ) (2015, Could 28). Could 28, 201. Retrieved from http://www.panynj.gov/path/pdf/PA-Minutes-5-28-15.pdf
  64. Tangel, A. (2015, Could 28). Group Chosen for La Guardia Redevelopment. Retrieved from The Wall Road Journal: http://www.wsj.com/articles/team-announced-for-new-la-guardia-airport-terminal-1432841527
  65. Governor Andrew M. Cuomo,. 2015 Alternative Agenda: Restoring Financial Alternative. 2015. Internet. 14 Oct. 2015.
  66. Airport Advisory Panel, A 21st Century Airport for the State of New York: The New LaGuardia,1-13
  67. Port Authority of New York and New Jersey (PANYNJ) (2015, Could 28). Could 28, 201. Retrieved from http://www.panynj.gov/path/pdf/PA-Minutes-5-28-15.pdf
  68. Airport Advisory Panel, A 21st Century Airport for the State of New York: The New LaGuardia,1-13
  69. PANYNJ, Port Authority Board Votes to Transfer Ahead on LaGuardia Airport Redevelopment, Could 28, 2015,http://www.panynj.gov/press-room/press-item.cfm?headLine_id=2218
  70. Port Authority of New York and New Jersey (PANYNJ) (2015, June 25). June 25, 2015 Retrieved from http://www.panynj.gov/corporate-information/pdf/PA-Minutes-6-25-15.pdf
  71. Irwin Rapoport, “Cleared for Takeoff: LaGuardia’s $4B Enterprise,” ConstructionEquipmentGuide.com, August 12, 2015, http://constructionequipmentguide.com/Cleared-for-Takeoff-LaGuardia’s-4B-Enterprise/25929/
  72. Irwin Rapoport, “Cleared for Takeoff: LaGuardia’s $4B Enterprise,” ConstructionEquipmentGuide.com, August 12, 2015, http://constructionequipmentguide.com/Cleared-for-Takeoff-LaGuardia’s-4B-Enterprise/25929/
  73. PANYNJ, LaGuardia Airport Central Terminal Constructing Alternative Mission Briefing E-book, 5-6.
  74. Ibid., 6
  75. Ibid., 7.
  76. Ibid., 6
  77. Ibid., 7.
  78. Ibid., 7.
  79. http://www.panynj.gov/airports/lga-airport-map.html
  80. Airport Advisory Panel, A 21st Century Airport for the State of New York: The New LaGuardia,6
  81. Port Authority of New York and New Jersey (PANYNJ) (2015, June 25). June 25, 2015 Retrieved from http://www.panynj.gov/corporate-information/pdf/PA-Minutes-6-25-15.pdf
  82. Port Authority of New York and New Jersey (PANYNJ) (2015, June 25). June 25, 2015 Retrieved from http://www.panynj.gov/corporate-information/pdf/PA-Minutes-6-25-15.pdf
  83. Port Authority of New York and New Jersey (PANYNJ) (2015, June 25). June 25, 2015 Retrieved from http://www.panynj.gov/corporate-information/pdf/PA-Minutes-6-25-15.pdf
  84. LaGuardia Worldwide Airport Redevelopment Mission, New York, United States of America. (n.d.). Retrieved from Airport Know-how: http://www.airport-technology.com/tasks/laguardia-international-airport-redevelopment-project-new-york/
  85. PANYNJ, LaGuardia Airport Central Terminal Constructing Alternative Mission Briefing E-book, 1
  86. Public Session -10-4-15. (2015). The Airports Council Worldwide – North America (ACI-NA), (p. 25).
  87. Public Session -10-4-15. (2015). The Airports Council Worldwide – North America (ACI-NA), (p. 25).
  88. Public Session -10-4-15. (2015). The Airports Council Worldwide – North America (ACI-NA), (p. 25)
  89. Public Session -10-4-15. (2015). The Airports Council Worldwide – North America (ACI-NA), (p. 25)
  90. Reuters, “UPDATE 2-Skanska consortium most well-liked bidder for $3.6 bln LaGuardia mission”, Could 29, 2015, http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/05/29/skanska-laguardia-idUSL5N0YK0VR20150529
  91. Public Session -10-4-15. (2015). The Airports Council Worldwide – North America (ACI-NA), (p. 25)
  92. PANYNJ, LaGuardia Airport Central Terminal Constructing Alternative Mission Briefing E-book, 51.
  93. Ibid., 1
  94. Ibid., 27
  95. Airport Advisory Panel, A 21st Century Airport for the State of New York: The New LaGuardia, 7.
  96. Ibid.
  97. Miguel Martin, “Megaprojects 460: One other Delay for LaGuardia Airport P3,” InfraPPP, February 25, 2015.
  98. PANYNJ, Port Authority Board Votes to Transfer Ahead on LaGuardia Airport Redevelopment, Could 28, 2015,http://www.panynj.gov/press-room/press-item.cfm?headLine_id=2218
  99. Delta Airways. “Delta Airways Publicizes September Quarter Revenue”. October 14, 2015. http://www.ir.delta.com/news-and-events/information. accessed October 24, 2015.
  100. Sleeping In Airports.“Worst Airports in North America 2015”.October 17, 2015. http://www.www.sleepinginairports.web/2015/worst-airports-north-america.htm. accessed October 23, 2015.
  101. Public-Non-public Partnership Coverage Casebook/San Juan, https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Public-Private_Partnership_Policy_Casebook/San_Juan
  102. Ibid.
  103. Miguel Martin, “Megaprojects 460: One other Delay for LaGuardia Airport P3,” InfraPPP, February 25, 2015.
  104. Barbara P. Alonso, Gregory R. Daniels and Roderick Devlin, “Market Replace: US Public Non-public Partnerships (P3) Sector”, Squire Sanders LLP with Sensible Regulation Finance, April 15, 2014, pg.7, http://www.squirepattonboggs.com/~/media/recordsdata/insights/publications/2014/04/squire-sanders-publishes-us-p3-market-update/recordsdata/squiresanderspublishesusp3marketupdate/fileattachment/squiresanderspublishesusp3marketupdate.pdf
  105. Public-Non-public Partnership Coverage Casebook/San Juan, https://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Public-Private_Partnership_Policy_Casebook/San_Juan
  106. Airport Advisory Panel, A 21st Century Airport for the State of New York: The New LaGuardia, 12.
  107. Ibid.
  108. PANYNJ, LaGuardia Airport Central Terminal Constructing Alternative Mission Briefing E-book, 38.
  109. Airport Advisory Panel, A 21st Century Airport for the State of New York: The New LaGuardia, 12.
  110. Airport Advisory Panel, A 21st Century Airport for the State of New York: The New LaGuardia, 7.
  111. PANYNJ, LaGuardia Airport Central Terminal Constructing Alternative Mission Briefing E-book, 34.
  112. Airport Advisory Panel, A 21st Century Airport for the State of New York: The New LaGuardia, 11.
  113. Ibid.
  114. PANYNJ, LaGuardia Airport Central Terminal Constructing Alternative Mission Briefing E-book, 8.
  115. Ibid., 6.
  116. Airport Advisory Panel, A 21st Century Airport for the State of New York: The New LaGuardia, 11.
  117. Toure, Madina.“Push for Girls & Minorities in LGA terminal mission ramps up.”October 15, 2015.http://www.TimesLedger.com. accessed October 23, 2015
  118. Mays, Jeff. “Black Ministers Threaten to Pull Assist For Cuomo over LaGuardia Plan.” October 5, 2015. http://www.DNAinfo.com. accessed October 23, 2015.
  119. Toure, Madina “Push for Girls & Minorities in LGA terminal mission ramps up.” October 15, 2015. http://www.timesledger.com. accessed October 23, 2015
  120. Ibid
  121. Toure, Madina. “Push for Girls & Minorities in LGA terminal mission ramps up”. October 15, 2015. http://www.timesledger.com. accessed October 23, 2015.
  122. New York State web site.http://www.governor.ny.gov. accessed October 23, 2015.
  123. Mays, Jeff. “Black Ministers Threaten to Pull Assist For Cuomo over LaGuardia Plan”.www.DNAino.com.October 5, 2015. accessed October 23, 2015.
  124. Port Authority New York New Jersey. http://www.panynj.com
  125. Ibid., 10.
  126. Ibid.
  127. PANYNJ, LaGuardia Airport Central Terminal Constructing Alternative Mission Briefing E-book, 32-33.
  128. Airport Advisory Panel, A 21st Century Airport for the State of New York: The New LaGuardia,10.
  129. Ibid.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *